Fondant vs Sugar Paste: What’s the Difference and Which Should You Use?

You’ve baked the perfect cake. Now comes the big decision: how will you decorate it? If you’re unsure whether to choose fondant or sugar paste, you’re not alone. The fondant vs sugar paste debate has puzzled home bakers and professionals for years.

Both options can give your cakes a stunning, polished finish, but they have important differences. In this guide, we’ll explain exactly what sets them apart, when to use each one, and how to get the best results with the products we recommend.

What Is Fondant?

Fondant is a smooth, pliable icing that’s rolled out and draped over cakes for a flawless finish. It’s sometimes referred to as rolled fondant. Fondant is popular for wedding cakes, novelty cakes, and any design that requires sharp edges and clean lines.

Key Features of Fondant

• Smooth, matte finish

• Flexible texture (easy to roll and shape)

• Holds its form well for structured designs

• Subtle vanilla-like taste

• Can be coloured or flavoured

What Is Sugar Paste?

In many countries (including the UK), sugarpaste and fondant are used interchangeably. However, in cake decorating terms, sugarpaste usually refers to a softer, more elastic version, often called modelling paste when used for creating flowers, figures, or decorations.

Key Features of Sugarpaste

• Slightly softer than standard fondant

• More elastic and forgiving when covering awkward shapes

• Ideal for delicate decorations and figurines

• Sets firm but not rock-hard

Our sugarpaste collection is perfect for both covering and modelling, giving you the flexibility to bring your cake designs to life. In fact, you'll find that our sugarpaste rolls further than most other brands.

Fondant vs Sugar Paste: The Main Differences

Texture and Workability

• Fondant is firmer, better for ultra-smooth cake coverings and tall cakes.

• Sugarpaste is softer and stretchier, perfect for covering odd shapes or for detailed decoration work. However, our sugarpaste range in over 50+ colours gives you both options due to the superior artisan technique we use in manufacturing.

Taste

Both have a mild sweetness. Some bakers find sugarpaste slightly softer on the palate.

Appearance

Fondant creates a flawless, satin-smooth look. Sugarpaste has a slightly softer appearance but is excellent for decorative shapes and ruffles.

Drying Time

Fondant dries slower, giving you more working time. Sugarpaste (especially modelling paste) dries faster, which is helpful when creating standing decorations.

Cost

Both products are similarly priced, but high-quality professional brands provide superior results. Check out our professional-grade sugarpaste products for the best value.

When to Use Fondant vs Sugar Paste

Use Fondant When:

• You want a flawless cake finish

• Covering wedding cakes or tiered cakes

• You need to emboss or texture large areas

Use Sugar Paste When:

• You’re making flowers, bows, figures, or intricate shapes

• Covering odd-shaped cakes

• You want faster drying for decorations

Tip: Many cake artists combine both: fondant for covering and sugar paste for detailing!

FAQs: Fondant vs Sugar Paste

Is sugar paste the same as fondant?

In the UK, yes. However, decorators often distinguish between fondant (covering) and sugar paste (decorating/modelling).

Which is easier to use?

Beginners may prefer sugar paste for its stretch and forgiving texture. Fondant offers more control for sharp edges and large surfaces.

Can I flavour fondant or sugar paste?

Absolutely! Our range of baking flavourings allows you to infuse your icing with anything from vanilla to citrus.

Does either icing hold up better in heat?

Fondant holds up slightly better under warm conditions. However, both should be stored and applied in a cool, dry environment.

Choosing the Right Products for Your Cake

At our store, we know that having the right product makes all the difference. That’s why we offer an expertly curated selection of:

• High-quality sugarpastes for flawless covering, decorations and fine details

• Essential cake flavourings, decorating tools and accessories to make every step easier.

Whether you’re a home baker or a pro, our products help you create cakes that wow.

Conclusion: Which Should You Choose?

The answer to the fondant vs sugar paste question depends on your cake goals:

• Want a smooth, polished finish? Normally we would say choose fondant, but with our superior sugarpaste product, we're more than confident that our sugarpaste is perfect for your creation.

• Creating flowers, figurines, or ruffles? Definitely go with sugarpaste.

• Need both? Many bakers use a combination for professional results.

Ready to take your cake decorating to the next level?
👉 Explore Our Sugarpaste Collection Now 👈